拍賣筆記 vol.519 邦瀚斯巴黎2026:吉賽爾專場,商代晚期青銅鐃 - Bonhams Paris 2026, Gisele Croes Sale, A Large Bronze Ritual Bell, Nao, Shang Dynasty

器呈橢圓截面,兩端尖削,器腹外凸,向下漸收,平底,下承中空管狀甬。腹壁兩面各飾五層共四十枚螺旋乳突,各層之間以方形雷紋帶分隔;口沿下方正中鑄一高度程式化的饕餮面。器底平素,飾一周卷雲紋。甬部鑄一圈凸起圓箍,飾雙饕餮,目睛突出,並有短扉棱。通體綠鏽,局部帶明亮綠鏽與鮮豔藍綠孔雀石與赤銅礦結晶,後配座。
以下為與邦瀚斯巴黎2026吉賽爾專場「商代晚期大型青銅鐃」(高57.4 cm,五層四十枚乳突)形制、風格相近的主要同類大型南方鐃(南方系,口向上立置,多單件出土,體量大,常見成排乳突+饕餮/雷紋),按博物館藏品與拍賣/私人收藏分類,附可查連結與簡要說明。
博物館藏品
藏處 | 館藏號/尺寸 | 簡要說明 | 連結 |
美秀美術館(Miho Museum,日本) | 高73.4 cm,寬約50 cm | 南方系最大型例之一(Shumei nao),橢圓截面、管狀甬,內外壁皆有紋飾,雙音特性曾被分析。與本件最接近的同組大型鐃。 | |
金貝爾藝術博物館(Kimbell Art Museum,達拉斯) | AP 1995.03,高48.3 cm | 約公元前10世紀,南方系,每面十八枚錐狀乳突(三層),中軸與口沿有饕餮,甬部圓箍飾雙饕餮。與本件同屬「乳突+雷紋帶」小群。 | |
芝加哥藝術博物館(Art Institute of Chicago) | 1924.243,高41.7 cm | 白金漢舊藏,西周(或商末西周初),南方(可能湖南),十八枚乳突(三層),中軸有扉棱樣裝飾。與本件、金貝爾、美秀同組。 | |
史密森學會/賽克勒(Smithsonian, Sackler) | S1999.120.1,高70 cm,寬52 cm | 約公元前1300–1200年,長江下游,大型,腹飾饕餮與龍紋+乳突,管狀甬。Paul Singer舊藏,體量與本件接近。 | |
波特蘭藝術博物館(Portland Art Museum) | 54.29(文獻記載) | 南方系大型鐃,與寧鄉老糧倉等出土例風格相近,常與美秀、金貝爾等並論。 | 見Bagley Shang Ritual Bronzes 及Sotheby’s相關說明 |
左:芝加哥藝術博物館;中:美秀博物館;右:弗利爾美術館
重要考古出土例(文獻/博物館介紹)
湖南寧鄉老糧倉、北峰灘等地:晚商大型鐃群(含十件同出者),多單件或窖藏,成排乳突或大獸面,為南方系典型。見Bagley 1987及Jenny So相關研究。
江西新干大洋洲商墓:有大型樂器(包括鐃類),與吳城文化相關,體量大、地域特色強。
浙江、福建、安徽等地:如長興、建甌黃科山等出土例,形制與美秀、芝加哥、金貝爾例相近,多口向上立置。
近年/重要拍賣與私人收藏例
來源 | 尺寸/說明 | 連結 |
邦瀚斯巴黎2026(吉賽爾專場,本件) | 高57.4 cm,五層四十枚乳突+中央饕餮,Gisèle Croës舊藏,估價:40-60萬歐元 | |
Sotheby’s 2022(吉賽爾相關,約2000年前後) | 高約47 cm,商末/西周初大型獸面紋鐃,Gisèle Croës 2000年,57.96萬美元售出 | |
Christie’s(2004年前後) | 高約61 cm,晚商/西周初,三層乳突+饕餮,南方系,22.03萬美元售出 | |
Sotheby’s 2014 | 高約(文獻),十八枚乳突,南方系,8.75萬美元售出 |

商末 / 西周初 青銅獸面紋鐃 Height 18½ in., 47 cm,September 20, 10:17 PM HKT
Estimate:500,000 - 700,000 USD
Lot Sold:579,600 USD
補充說明
核心同組:美秀、金貝爾(AP 1995.03)、芝加哥藝術博物館(1924.243)與本件最接近——皆為南方大型鐃,以成排乳突為主、層間雷紋帶分隔、中軸對稱、甬部圓箍飾饕餮。
體量:美秀(73.4 cm)與賽克勒(70 cm)為目前公開最大級;本件57.4 cm亦屬超大型。
地域:主要為湖南、江西、浙江、安徽等長江中下游,多單件窖藏或祭祀坑,與北方安陽成套小型鐃系統不同。
雙音特性:美秀例曾做音響分析,證實可擊出「遂」「鼓」兩音,本件應同具此功能。

根據美秀美術館《Catalogue of the Miho Museum, South Wing》(1997年)第170–171頁注4,以及該館官方頁面記載,針對其收藏的大型南方系鐃(Shumei nao,高73.4 cm)進行過專門的音響測試與分析,結果如下:
核心發現
該鐃因器身呈透鏡形/橢圓截面(lens-shaped / elliptical cross-section),而非正圓,擊打時會產生兩種主要振動模式,從而發出不止一個音。
擊打位置與音名:
在長側中央(center of a long side)擊打 → 發出「遂音」(sui tone)。
在靠近口緣、距邊緣約三分之二處(two-thirds of the way to the edge)擊打 → 發出「鼓音」(gu tone)。
音程關係:遂音比鼓音低一個大二度(a major second below the gu tone)。
研究出處
美秀美術館目錄明確記載:「The acoustics of the Shumei bell have been tested and analyzed. ... See Falkenhausen, Hiller, and Weninger, forthcoming.」
此研究由羅泰(Lothar von Falkenhausen)等人進行(當時標為forthcoming),並與羅泰1993年專著《Suspended Music: Chime-Bells in the Culture of Bronze Age China》中的中國青銅時代編鐘音響理論相呼應。
物理與音樂意義
雙音原理:橢圓截面使原本在圓形鐘上簡併(degenerate)的振動模式分裂成頻率略有差異的成對模式。擊打「遂」點主要激發一組模式,擊打「鼓」點則激發另一組,從而產生兩個不同音高。
與後來編鐘的關係:這一特性在後來的西周、春秋戰國編鐘(yongzhong等)中被充分開發,使一套鐘能以較少數量的鐘體演奏更豐富的音階。南方大型鐃雖多單件出土,但其雙音能力已具備後來「一鐘雙音」的技術基礎。
演奏方式:與北方小型成套鐃不同,南方大型鐃口向上立置於甬上,以木槌自外擊打。演奏者可透過控制擊打位置,在同一面鐃上獲得至少兩個音。
與邦瀚斯本件的關聯
邦瀚斯巴黎2026吉賽爾專場的這件商代晚期大型鐃(高57.4 cm),與美秀例同屬「成排乳突+雷紋帶+中軸對稱」的南方大型鐃小群。形制、截面與紋飾布局高度相近,因此應同具雙音特性——即擊打長側中央得遂音,擊打近口緣處得鼓音,兩者約相差大二度。
這也是南方系大型鐃作為「國之重器」的重要技術特徵之一:體量宏大帶來音量,橢圓截面帶來雙音,共同服務於祭祖與典禮中的權力節奏與溝通神靈的功能。

商代晚期 約公元前十一世紀
大型青銅鐃
高57.4 cm(22½英寸)× 寬37 cm(14½英寸)
GISÈLE CROËS: A LEGACY
2026年 12月 10日, 10:30 CET
€400,000 - €600,000
HK$3,400,000 - HK$5,100,000
來源:
匯寶閣古美術,香港,1999年
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient,布魯塞爾,2002年
瑞士私人收藏,2010年
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient,布魯塞爾,2015年
展覽著錄:
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient,《Treasures of Ancient China, Part 2》,第二十一屆古董雙年展,巴黎,2002年9月20-29日,第22-25頁
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient,《Ancient Chinese Treasures》,布魯塞爾,歐洲藝術與古董博覽會,荷蘭馬斯特裏赫特, 2010年3月12-21日,第36-37頁
此件體量極大、鑄造精湛的青銅鐃,以多層凸起乳突為主體紋飾,充分展現了商代晚期至西周早期南方鑄銅作坊在技術、創造力與傳統上的高度成就。
大型乃至超大型青銅鐘的出土,多見於當時封建上層貴族墓葬,表明其使用嚴格限於社會最高階層。這類氣勢恢宏的禮樂器,實為「國之重器」,其聲調在祭祖與重大典禮中標誌權力節奏。鐘屬於更廣泛的「雅樂」系統——西周時期已制度化、標準化的宮廷禮樂體系。羅泰(Lothar von Falkenhausen)在《Suspended Music: Chime Bells in the Culture of Bronze Age China》(1993)中對中國青銅時代編鐘的功能有詳盡討論。其深沉悠長的音響,被認為具有溝通祖先與神明的力量,可向神靈世界傳達訊息。
商周時期的禮樂器大體分為兩類,尺寸均可自小型至超大型:鎛(bo)懸掛於架上,口向下;鐃(nao)則口向上直立放置。鐃器身橢圓截面、兩端尖削,下承中空管狀甬,口緣朝上。與鎛一樣,鐃內部並無鐘舌,以槌自外擊打發聲。因擊打位置不同,同一面鐃至少可發出兩種音高。體量越大,音量越宏。其特殊形制使單一樂器能產生多音。日本美秀美術館所藏一件相近大型鐃的音響分析顯示:敲擊長側中央可得「遂」音,敲擊近邊緣三分之二處可得「鼓」音(《Catalogue of the Miho Museum, South Wing》,1997,第170–171頁,注4)。這類大型鐃很可能與其他樂器合奏。鎛或負責標示節奏,而能發出雙音的鐃則負責旋律本身。
貝格利(Robert Bagley)指出,鐃主要是南方產物。他認為帶管狀甬、口向上放置的大型鐘在安陽商代遺址雖有出現,但安陽期以後即從北方禮器系統中消失,同時南方大型鐃卻持續發展。此類大型鐃主要出土於南方,尤以湖南北部為多,亦見於長江中下游的湖北、江西、安徽、江蘇與浙江等地(見Bagley, Shang Ritual Bronzes in the Arthur M. Sackler Collections, 1987, pp. 727–731)。
商至西周時期,南方廣大地區形成了獨特的用銅與鑄銅文化,常鑄造體量極大的鐘。南方鑄工熟悉北方的鑄造技術與紋飾,並加以運用。南方作坊所製之鐃,體量普遍極大,形制與紋飾略有變化。與長江以北的禮樂鐘不同,這些鐃多單件出土,而非成套,且多發現於孤立窖藏,缺乏明確的地層關係或其他伴出物可助斷代。所有此類鐃皆以巨大體量、凸起的獸面衍生母題或成排乳突、以及甬部凸起圓箍或鼓起為共同特徵。
就風格而言,本件屬於一小群以成排乳突為主、乳突之間以窄帶方折雷紋分隔、並對稱圍繞中軸脊線排列的大型鐃。同組其他例子包括:日本美秀美術館所藏一件極相近例(《Catalogue of the Miho Museum, South Wing》,1997,第170–171頁);芝加哥藝術博物館藏一件(館藏號1924.243);以及達拉斯金貝爾藝術博物館藏一件(館藏號AP 1995.03)。
A MAGNIFICENT AND VERY RARE LARGE BRONZE RITUAL BELL, NAO
Late Shang Dynasty, ca. 11th century BC
Of elliptical cross section with pointed ends, the convex sides tapering to a flat base raised on a hollow, tubular shank, each side cast with forty raised spiralling bosses arranged in five horizontal registers, each row separated by bands of squared leiwen, all below a central, highly stylised taotie mask below the rim, the flat underside of the bell cast with a band of scrolls, the tubular shank cast with a raised rounded collar decorated with two taotie masks with prominent eyes and short flanges, the bronze patinated to a greenish tone with areas of bright green and vivid blue cuprite and malachite encrustation, later stand.
57.4 cm (22 1/2 in.) high x 37 cm (14 1/2 in.) wide (2).
商代晚期 約公元前十一世紀 青銅鐃
MAGNIFIQUE ET IMPORTANTE CLOCHE RITUELLE EN BRONZE NAO
Fin de la dynastie Shang, vers XIe siècle av. J.-C.
10 December 2026, 10:30 CET
Paris, Avenue Hoche
€400,000 - €600,000
HK$3,400,000 - HK$5,100,000
Provenance:
Wui Po Kok Antique Co., Ltd., Hong Kong, 1999
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient, Brussels, 2002
A Swiss private collection, 2010
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient, Brussels, 2015
Published, Illustrated and Exhibited:
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient, Treasures of Ancient China, Part 2, XXIe Biennale des Antiquaires, Paris, 20 - 29 September 2002, pp. 22-25
Gisèle Croës Arts d'Extrême Orient, Ancient Chinese Treasures, Brussels, The European Fine Art Fair, Maastricht, 12 - 21 March 2010, pp. 36-37
This extraordinarily large, magnificently cast bronze bell with its boldly cast design of multiple rows of raised bosses is an important testimony to the skills, creativity and traditions of bronze-working foundries made in the South of China during the late Shang and early Zhou dynasties.
Discoveries of bronze bells of large and very large size in tombs of the feudal elite of this period demonstrate that their use was restricted to the very upper levels of society. Clearly exuding power, such impressive ceremonial bells must be considered instruments of statecraft, whose tones marked the rhythms of power during important ceremonies and rituals venerating the ancestors. Bells were part of a wider music system known as yayue, a codified, systemic institution of classical Court and ritual music implemented and standardised during the Western Zhou dynasty, see Lothar von Falkenhausen's study and discussion of the role of bells in China, Suspended Music: Chime Bells in the Culture of Bronze Age China, Berkeley, 1993. With their deep ringing tones, their sound was believed to have the power to communicate with ancestors and deities, conveying messages to the spirit world.
In Shang and Zhou dynasty China, ceremonial bells comprised two principal categories, both cast in sizes ranging from small to very large. Bo bells such as Lot 61 were designed to be suspended from a large frame, their elliptical opening facing down. Nao bells such as the present example, on the other hand, were intended to stand facing upwards. Of elliptical cross-section and with pointed ends, nao bells were mounted on a hollow, tubular shank, the curved mouth facing up. Like the suspended bo bell, there is no indication that nao had a clapper. They were sounded by striking the surface from the outside with a mallet, the player obtaining at least two different notes from the bell depending on where it was struck. The greater the size of the bell, the greater the volume of sound. The distinctive shape of the nao bell allowed for more than a single note. An analysis of a closely related large nao in the collection of the MIHO Museum, Shigaraki, Shiga Prefecture, Japan, has demonstrated that two tones could be produced when the bell was struck at different points near the rim, one, at the centre of a long side (the sui tone), the second, two-thirds of the way to the edge (gu tone), the results published in Catalogue of the Miho Museum, South Wing, Japan, 1997, pp. 170-171, footnote 4. It is possible that these large bells were played in ensembles with other musical instruments. While bo bells may have served to accent the tempo or underlying rhythm, it was the musical, two-toned nao bells that produced the music.
In his discussion of ceremonial bells, Robert Bagley notes that nao bells were products of southern provinces. Bagley argues that larger bronze bells with tubular handles designed to stand with the rim facing upwards were found in Shang sites at Anyang but disappeared from the repertory of ritual bronzes after the Anyang period. At the same time larger bells of nao type continued to flourish in the south. Large bronze bells such as this example, have been excavated from different sites in southern China, primarily in northern Hunan province, but also further east along the Yangzi river basin, in Hubei, Jiangxi, Anhui, Jiangsu and Zhejiang, see Robert W. Bagley, Shang Ritual Bronzes in the Arthur M. Sackler Collections, Washington, D.C., 1987, pp. 727-731.
During the Shang and Western Zhou, a distinctive bronze using and bronze casting culture developed in this large region often producing bells known for their very large size. Southern bronze-casters were familiar with northern casting methods and designs and applied them in their work. The nao from this group made in bronze casting workshops in the south were generally made in extremely large size and with slight variations in their form and decoration. Unlike ceremonial bells made north of the Yangzi river, these nao bells were found singly and not in sets, in isolated hoards with no or few clues to dating through stratigraphic relationships or association with other artifacts. All of these nao bells share the large size, and designs that incorporate massive protruding mask-derived motifs or rows of conical bosses, as well as raised collars or bulges around the shank of the bell.
Stylistically, the present nao bell belongs to a small and distinct group of large nao cast with angular keyfret scrolls arranged in narrow bands between rows of conical bosses symmetrically arranged around a central vertical rib. Other nao bells in this group include a closely related example in the collection of the MIHO Museum, Shigaraki, Shiga Prefecture, Japan, illustrated in Catalogue of the Miho Museum, South Wing, Japan, 1997, pp. 170-171. Two other examples of this type include a large nao in the collection of the Art Institute, Chicago (accession no. 1924.243), and a nao in the collection of the Kimbell Art Museum, Dallas (accession no. AP 1995.03).





Comments