拍賣筆記 vol.256 初唐白釉梅瓶：強定隋代僅304萬港元成交 - Tang Dyansty White Glaze Moping, Sold for 3.04m HKD, a 70% drop from Highest Records
- SACA
- Oct 30
- 3 min read
出土紀錄均為初唐，因為市場原因被強行歸為隋代，可惜仍表現欠佳，從高峰的1000萬港元左右跌至304萬艱難成交。隋白擊鼓傳花的遊戲是否能持續，這是一個很值得關注的課題。
Archaeological records consistently date such examples to the early Tang period, yet for market-driven reasons they are often forcefully reclassified as Sui dynasty works. Unfortunately, this strategy has proven ineffective: prices have fallen sharply from their previous peak of around HKD 10 million to a struggling hammer price of HKD 3.04 million. Whether the “Sui white” game of passing the parcel can continue remains a question worthy of close observation.
抱樸山居珍藏
隋 白釉梅瓶 （唐代）
SUI DYNASTY (581-618)
成交價
港元 3,048,000
估價
港元 600,000 – 港元 800,000
13 3⁄8 in. (34 cm.) high
來源
2000年入藏於台灣
拍品專文
此梅瓶小唇口、短頸、豐肩、腹漸收至平底，通體施白釉，釉質瀅潤均勻，並有細開片。整體造型飽滿，端莊敦厚，與釉色相互托襯，不僅為隋白瓷中的難得一作，更為早期梅瓶中之典範。
隋朝白瓷燒造時間短暫，傳世作品稀少，多見盃及小罐，如此瓶之器形及尺寸之作品極為罕見。美國舊金山亞洲藝術博物館藏有一件形制近乎相同之例，為Avery Brundage舊藏，館藏編號B60P155。北京故宮博物院藏有一件器形相似、帶寬口之隋白釉罐，載於故宮博物院藏文物珍品全集《晉唐瓷器》，香港，2016年，頁64，編號58；另藏有一唐代白釉梅瓶，惟腹收幅度較大，藏品編號：新00136908。
拍賣市場上曾出現一極為近似之隋白釉梅瓶，於東京中央2022年9月10日拍賣，拍品481號；另一瓶身較修長之隋白釉蓋罐，為藍理捷舊藏，2023年3月20日於紐約邦瀚斯拍賣，拍品10號；另一白釉梅瓶，2024年5月30日於香港佳士得拍賣，拍品2848號。
The Property of a North American Collector
A RARE LARGE WHITE-GLAZED MEIPING
SUI DYNASTY (581-618) （should be Tang Dynasty)
Price realised
HKD 3,048,000
Estimate
HKD 600,000 – HKD 800,000
A RARE LARGE WHITE-GLAZED MEIPING
SUI DYNASTY (581-618)
13 3⁄8 in. (34 cm.) high
PROVENANCE
Acquired in Taiwan in 2000
It is extremely rare to find Sui dynasty white ware of this form and size, as this type of ware is more commonly found in cups and smaller jars.
A similarly shaped meiping is preserved at the San Francisco Asian Art Museum, The Avery Brundage Collection, object number B60P155. A similarly shaped jar with a wider mouth from the Sui dynasty is preserved in the Palace Museum, Beijing and illustrated in The Complete Collection of Treasures of the Palace Museum, Porcelain of Jin and Tang Dynasties, Hong Kong, 2016, p. 64, no.58. A closely related meiping from Tang dynasty with a more exaggerated lower body and smaller lipped mouth, is preserved in the Palace Museum, Beijing collection number xin-00136908.
Compare to a similar Sui dynasty white-glazed meiping, sold at Tokyo Chuo Auction, 10 September 2022, lot 481. Compare also to a Sui dynasty white-glazed jar and cover with a taller and more slender body, formerly with J. J. Lally & Co., sold at Bonhams New York, 20 March 2023, lot 10. Compare to another almost identical meiping sold at Christie's Hong Kong, 30 May 2024, lot 2848.
Comments